Who’s Got The Best Pizza In Winston-Salem?

To keep the lights on, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. Our review process.

Pizza is one of America’s favorite foods; finding a good pizza is worth searching for. We often call a few chains for take-out, like Domino’s, Papa John’s, and Pizza Hut. But you will find local pizzerias offer traditional pizzas and much more. Check out our list of Winston-Salem pizza places and find the one you love.

Americano pizza from Cugino Forno jpg
Americano pizza from Cugino Forno.
Photo by Aniya Ellison for MyWinston-Salem.com, © Cover Story Media, Inc. 2023.

A Slice of Napoli

CLOSED. A new restaurant, Pizza Greco, has opened in its place.

Brothers Pizzeria

Brothers is a favorite in Winston-Salem and very popular. They pride themselves on using fresh ingredients and offer classic pizzas. In addition to their standard pizza they have specialty ones such as cheesesteak, chicken bacon ranch, chicken Alfredo, and stuffed pizzas – like stuffed meat lovers and stuffed spinach and ricotta. They offer calzones and strombolis too.

Brothers Menu

  • 214 W 4th Street, Winston-Salem, NC
  • 336-842-0587
  • Hours
    • Tues-Thurs, 4 pm-11:30 pm
    • Fri & Sat, 4 pm-2:30 am
    • Sunday, 4 pm-10 pm
    • Closed Monday

Burke Street Pizza

Burke Street Pizza specializes in authentic thin-crust New York-style pizza at their two locations. They also serve appetizers, salads, hot and cold hero sandwiches, specialty pizzas, and lunch specials.

Lasagna Pizza?! Never heard of it!

Burke St MenuRobinhood Menu

  • 1140 Burke Street, Winston-Salem, NC
  •  336-721-0011
    •  Hours Mon-Thurs, 11 am-10 pm
    • Fri & Sat, 11 am-11 pm
    • Sun, 11 am-10 pm
  •  3352 Robinhood Road, Winston-Salem, NC
  •  336-760-4888
  •  Hours
    • Mon-Thurs, 11 am-9 pm
    • Fri & Sat, 11 am-10 pm
    • Sun, 11 am-9 pm

Coppola’s Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant

Coppola’s is an Italian restaurant with a full menu of pasta, house specialties, baked pasta, sandwiches, strombolis, calzones, and NY-style pizza.

Coppola’s WebsiteCoppola’s Menu (PDF)

  • Reynolda Commons Shopping Center, 3512 Yadkinville Road, Winston-Salem, NC
  • 336-922-1190
  • Hours
    • Tues-Thurs, 11 am-10 pm
    • Fri & Sat, 11 am-11 pm
    • Sun, 11 am-10 pm
    • Closed Monday

Cugino Forno Pizza

Cugino Forno serves authentic Neapolitan-style pizza made with 80% of the ingredients imported from the best sources in Italy. It is baked in a 900-degree oven imported from Naples containing stone from Mt Vesuvius, contributing to its unique taste.

Cugino Forno Menu

two pizzas in boxes covered with toppings
Popular pizza options from Cugino Forno.
Photo by Aniya Ellison for MyWinston-Salem.com, © Cover Story Media, Inc. 2023.
  • 486 N. Patterson Avenue #115, Winston-Salem, NC
  • 336-448-0102
  • Hours
    • Mon-Thurs, 11 am-9 pm
    • Fri & Sat, 11 am-10 pm
    • Sun, 11 am- 9 pm

Elizabeth’s Pizza Italian Restaurant

Elizabeth’s Pizza features NY-style pizza, Sicilian pizza, specialty pizzas, appetizers, salads, calzones, strombolis, subs, sandwiches, and classic pasta dishes.

Elizabeth’s Pizza Italian Restaurant Menu

  • 3278 Silas Creek Parkway, Winston Salem, NC
  • 336-768-0605
  • Hours
    • Mon-Sat, 11 am-9 pm
    • Sun, 11:30 am-9 pm

Mario’s Big Pizza

Mario’s Pizza offers delicious meals for the whole family in three locations in Winston-Salem, featuring NY-style pizza, subs, wings, calzones, Italian entrees, and desserts.

Cloverdale MenuHarvey St MenuHanes Mall Menu

  • 2205 Cloverdale Avenue SW, Winston-Salem, NC
  • 336-602-1410
  • 266 Harvey Street (Off Stratford), Winston-Salem, NC;
  • 336-701-5550
  • 1066 Hanes Mall Blvd, Winston-Salem, NC
  • 336-768-0057
  • Hours
    • Mon-Thurs 11 am-9 pm
    • Fri & Sat, 11 am-9:30 pm
    • Sun, 12 pm-8 pm

Mellow Mushroom

Mellow Mushroom is a funky, art-centric restaurant that is fun and laid back with delicious pizzas, burgers, hoagies and sandwiches, salads, munchies, calzones, and a build-your-own pizza menu selection. Vegan and gluten-free choices are also available.

Mellow Mushroom Menu

small pizzas on table
Create your own pizza at Mellow Mushroom.
Photo by Aniya Ellison for MyWinston-Salem.com, © Cover Story Media, Inc. 2023.
  • 314 W4th Street, Winston-Salem, NC
  • 336-245-2820
  • Hours
    • Mon-Thurs 11 am-10 pm
    • Fri & Sat, 11 am- 11 pm
    • Sun, 11 am-10 pm

Mission Pizza Napoletano

Mission Pizza is housed in a cozy space in the Arts District and serves authentic Napoletano pizza baked in their homemade Stefano Ferrara oven at 900 degrees. They also offer a full menu of Italian-inspired pasta, salads, and vegetables.

  • 707 Trade Street NW, Winston-Salem, NC
  • 336-893-8217
    • Wed & Thurs, 5 pm-9 pm
    • Fri & Sat, 5 pm-9:30 pm
    • Closed Sunday, Monday, Tuesday

Pizza Greco

Pizza Greco is a new restaurant that opened where A Slice of Napoli was. It is owned by the same people who own TJ’s Deli. It has counter service and first reviews I have heard are good. NY pizza, Sicilian, pizza, calzones, strombolis, subs, gyros, and souvlaki are some of what they offer.

Pizza Greco Menu

  • 5089 Country Club Road, Winston-Salem, NC
  • 336-930-1500
  • Hours
    • Mon-Thurs, 11 am-9 pm
    • Fri & Sat, 11 am-10 pm
    • Closed Sunday

The Pizza Place

The Pizza Place offers pizza, hot and cold subs, delicious sides, pasta, specialty pizza, wings, salads, and specials. Women-owned and operated, they also do catering.

Pizza Place Menu

  • Parkway Plaza, 1155 Silas Creek Parkway, Winston-Salem, NC
  • 336-722-0021
  • Hours
    • Mon-Thurs, 11 am-9:30 pm
    • Fri & Sat 11 am-10 pm
    • Closed Sunday

Vinnie’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

Vinnie’s offers an extensive lunch and dinner menu featuring appetizers, hot and cold subs, salads, pasta, specialty entrees, baked pasta dishes, strombolis, calzones, and NY-style pizza.

Vinnie’s Menu

  • Shoppes at Oliver’s Crossing, 5076 Peter’s Creel Parkway, Winston-Salem, NC
  • 336-893-7898
  • Hours
    • Mon-Sun, 11 am-10 pm

Whitaker Square Pizza

Whitaker Square offers appetizers, salads, wraps, hot or cold subs, wraps, pasta, stromboli, calzones, NY style, Sicilian, and Grandma style Pizza, as well as gourmet and specialty pizzas. They also have specials available 11 am-3 pm.

Whitaker Square Menu

  • Whitaker Square, 1981 N. Peace Haven Road, Winston-Salem, NC
  • 336-660-0400
  • Hours
    • Mon, Wed, Thurs, 11 am-9 pm
    • Fri, Sat, Sun, 11 am-9:30 pm
    • Closed Tuesday

Zito’s Pizzeria & Grill

Zito’s specializes in pizza made with locally milled, organic flour. They strive to use the freshest, cleanest ingredients in all their dishes. Besides pizza, pizza boats, stromboli, and calzones, they offer salads, Greek cuisine, poutine, a vegan menu, and gluten-free choices.

Zito’s Menu

  • 3030 Healy Drive, Winston-Salem, NC
  • 336-765-9486
  • Hours
    • Mon-Fri, 11:30 am-8:30 pm
    • Sat, 4 pm-8:30 pm
    • Closed Sunday

Italian Restaurants In Winston-Salem

If you want Italian but desire more than pizza, look at the best Italian restaurants in Winston-Salem. You will find a variety of them to choose from, with their menus. You are sure to find just what you are looking for.

Where do you get your favorite pizza? Let us know in the comments.

The information provided through this website should not be used to diagnose or treat a health problem or disease; it is not intended to offer any legal opinion or advice or a substitute for professional safety advice or professional care. Please consult your health care provider, attorney, or product manual for professional advice. Products and services reviewed are provided by third parties; we are not responsible in any way for them, nor do we guarantee their functionality, utility, safety, or reliability. Our content is for educational purposes only.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments